Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Anti-Polonism

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

[edit] Deletion, why?

The answer is very simple. This article contains lies, spreaded by people who either are anti-german Racists or do not know what they are talking about. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, and that means that it cannot be based on lies! Best greetings, Micha.

[edit] Deletion, why not?

This is a discussion page. Your contribution to the discussion is very thin. You offer no arguments, just a POV.

First, it is incorrect to attribute 'lies' to other people, because a lie presuposes an intention (of deliberately telling untruths) and you cannot know other people's intentions. you can only prove that what they say is not true, and for this you have given no argument whatsoever.

Second, you attribute unverifiable intentions to people who wrote this article ('they are anti-German racists or do not know what they are talking about'). It is incorrect to fight other people's intentions because you cannot know them. You can only prove that they are wrong - and you did not. Their intentions are less relevant than the truthfulness of what they write.

I believe that you have offered nothing of use to this discussion. Best greetings, Michel.