Talk:Ancient (Stargate)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

You have new messages (last change).
This article is part of WikiProject Stargate, an attempt to build a comprehensive and detailed guide to Stargate on Wikipedia.
stargate-sg-1-atlantis - edit talk + - project - talk + - join 


Major problems with this page:

1. "And, in fact had evolved originally on Earth several million years ahead of Humans."

The ancients MAY have evolved on Earth, but it's very unlikely. According to the first episode of Star Gate: Atlantis, the ancients whole purpose in life was to reseed the galaxy with humanoid life after a plague had wiped most of it from the universe. In this means, the ancients would have seeded the Milky Way, as well as the Asgard galaxy, and probably any other race that has since developed, including us humans.

Yet SG: Atlantis episode "Before I sleep" (think it's S1E15) has some Ancient implicitly tell Dr. Weir that they were the first evolution of Humans on Earth. I'm starting to think that a) the plot is broken there b) the Alterans had a collective loss of memory regarding where they came from during their time residing in the Milky Way c) there was another race on Earth that actually evolved there but merged with the Alterans (who did come from outside the Milky Way).

2. "However, there came a time that many of the Ancients "ascended" to a higher plane of existence (spatial) to escape a plague that was destroying their population. Around this time, one of the ancient's cities on Earth, Atlantis, left Earth and went to the Pegasus galaxy, where it settled on the huge ocean of a planet with barely any land."

The "plague" happened long before the ancients left to go to the Pagasus galaxy. The entire reason for them going was to reseed that galaxy with humanoid life. Why would they go there if the plague would just wipe out the life they seeded eventually?

3. "When the Atlantean Ancients returned, the plague was spreading."

Where are you getting this information? Are you creating it like fan-fic, or are do you actually have show references?

The Plague happened WAY before the ancients seeded ANY galaxies. It was their job to reseed the galaxy after the Plague had already killed off all living beings except the ancients (they were carriers).

4. "After breeding with the humans who had the same physical appearance, some ascended, and became god-like beings"

What?!? See, now I know you're making this up. There is not one single reference for this in the show at all. The reason why some humans (1/16,000) can use ancient technology is due to the fact that we're evolving into ancients, or rather we're evolving the neccessary biology that will allow us to be like the ancients (regeneration abilities, healing others, empathic abilities, so on). The ancients seeded planets with their DNA, and the life that evolved from that DNA will eventually have the same abilities as the ancients once had. They're repopulating their race, not having sex with cavemen.

5. "The Ancients are a member of the alliance of four great races."

The ancients WERE (past tense) part of the alliance of four great races. They're ascended now, and their rules prohibit them from interfering in lesser races advancement. They no longer contribute to the alliance, thus they're no longer members.


I'm going to put together some real references from some real sources, and then rewrite this article, because as it stands now, it's mostly fan-fic inspired, not actually factual pertaining to the series.


I think its getting pretty obvious that ancients are just humans, on the episode where they find the ancient girl in antarctica it said something about the humans being another cycle with the ancients haven previously chosen to return. I don't know, check it out. I'm not a anorak and I saw that episode eons ago --Josquius 22:33, 15 Oct 2004 (UTC)

In the ending of this season, they state that the wraith are evolved from the parasite and the humans. I'm not updating the page directly because I don't have detailed references and it's messed up otherwise anyway. DÅ‚ugosz

Actually, IIRC it's only speculated at by the human main characters on account of the similarities between Wraith DNA and both humans and the tick-like bugs. They could well be wrong about it, they've been wrong about other stuff before as well (their original speculation on why Teyla could sense Wraith, for example). I don't have the detailed references handy either, but I'll continue tinkering with the article as I come across them. Bryan 00:38, 30 Mar 2005 (UTC)

Ascention happened AFTER they left for Pegasus! They were still researching it on Atlantis!! (See Hide And Seek) This will require a pretty big rewrite.

Also, two other ways the Ancients combatted the Plague were the failed Time Machine from Window of Opprotunity and the Dakara Superweapon. I'm not as good a writer as some other people, so its probably best if someone else fixed the myriad of errors.


Contents

[edit] Ancient History

There are many things wrong with the history of the Ancients.

  • 1. If the ori wanted the atlantiens to worship them wouldn’t they have been protected by the ascended beings that that thought is was wrong to interfere in lower technologically advanced beings.
  • 2. I thought that there were two groups of ascended beings the ori and ascended beings that that thought is was wrong to interfere in lower technologically advanced beings.
  • 3. If the atlantiens were the ascended beings that that thought is was wrong to interfere in lower technologically advanced beings why didn’t the ori enslave them to worship before they ascended.
  • 4. If the wraith evolved by sucking the blood of the ancients than in order for the wraith to be 100 times more numerous they would have had too suck the blood of 99% of the ancients.
  • 5. It would take decades at best for the wraith to evolve to the point of space travel capable of destroying the ancients.
  • 6. The wraith can not survive without human food.
  • 7. Why would the ancients allow there people to be killed off for decades allowing the wraith population to grow and evolve to the point of space travel capable of destroying the ancients.


[edit] Who asended first the Ancients or the Ori

Please discuse this.

[edit] Oma Desala Redirects Here

Why, she's a major character, she has merit for a seperate article. 21:41, 29 May 2006 (UTC)

  • I agree. She should have a seprate article. Tobyk777 07:23, 4 June 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Move Request

In the interest of encyclopedic perfection, this page should be moved to Alteran as the only reason for calling the Alteran's Ancients is because no one ever knew their proper name, they were just the gate builders, the ancients, the ancestors, but now we have a proper name for them. Carterhawk 01:50, 16 August 2005 (UTC)

I disagree. They're still almost exclusively referred to as the Ancients, and that's what everybody knows them by. bob rulz 03:17, August 16, 2005 (UTC)
That doesnt make it right though. nine of years of not having enough info has ended. It would be like calling the Ori The Ancients Evil Cousins or something. The Alterans left the Ori, the Ori attacked the Alterans, and they both ascended. So much nicer than Ancients. We need to find the very first reference to Ancient in the show, see who said it and why, probably just sounded better than Gate Builders.... Carterhawk 03:52, 16 August 2005 (UTC)
Oppose. Per Wikipedia:Naming conventions (common names), we use common names, not official names. They are commonly known as the Ancients and that is how they should stay. Dragons flight 04:47, August 16, 2005 (UTC)
Oppose. Ancients is the common name used in the series. In fact, a lot of fans are not avare of the Alterans name. Alteran can be created as a redirect, if necessary. - Andromeda 08:56, 16 August 2005 (UTC)
Oppose. The show established the term Alterans in S9E02 IIRC, only a few weeks ago. Aside from die-hard fans, nobody nows the it...yet. -- 84.156.170.236 10:45, 17 August 2005 (UTC)
Oppose. "Ancients" are what they're called now, by almost everyone in the Milky Way (both real and fictional :). That's their common name, so that's what the article should be titled. Bryan 15:35, 17 August 2005 (UTC)
Aren't they from Altair? If so, isn't the name actually Altairan? -Sean Curtin 03:09, August 19, 2005 (UTC)
I doubt it. Altair is only 17 light years away, and as an A-class star isn't much like the Sun. The Ancients apparently came from outside the Milky Way entirely. Bryan 05:34, 19 August 2005 (UTC)
Oppose. "Ancients" is the more commonly-used names. And for that matter, we've not yet gotten any confirmation as to whether all Ancients are Alterans. The name could for all we know just apply to the ones who aren't Ori. Redxiv 23:53, 19 August 2005 (UTC)
Oppose. In the episode "The Fifth Race", O'Niel reads off 'Noo Ani Anqueetus', Ancient for 'We are the Ancients'. Maybe 'Alteran' refers to a particular 'nationality' or clan of Ancients, as 'Lantian' refers to those Ancients who went with Atlantis to Pegasus.
Oppose. It should stay as ancients, if your going to do everything by its old name, then Americans, Australians, new zealanders are all British, most south americans are Aztec or Spanish, and Canadians are actually British and French….

It was requested that this article be renamed but there was no consensus for it be moved. violet/riga (t) 14:08, 21 August 2005 (UTC)

[edit] Post-fall Ancient/Human Interaction

Its a well known fact that there was intermarriage between the returning Lantians and humans. Anyhow, I was wondering what theories there were as to the connection between the Romans and the Ancients as well as the simmilarity between spoken ancient and spoken latin.

If it's a "well known fact" that there was intermarriage, could you provide some references so that we could make the article clearer on this matter? As for theories about other connections, keep in mind the no original research policy. We need to keep fan speculation segregated and clearly labelled. Bryan 05:04, 7 September 2005 (UTC)
Two words: Explain ATA. There had to be intermarriage. LD 9/17/05
If I were to explain ATA, then that would be original research on my part. Please point out an external reference of some kind where ATA is explained in this manner. Bryan 01:22, 22 September 2005 (UTC)

[edit] Who changed it to "Altairans"?

Where does your information come from? All I know is, scifi.com has the Ancients listed as "Altera" or "Alterans". They have the scripts; they know more; hence what they say is correct. Thus, I am changing it all back to "Alterans", and I beleive I have the community behind me. LD 9/21/05

The Altairans (notice the spelling) are the race that built Harlan who later built android replicas of SG-1. Aarlin81 22:43, 16 May 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Ancient written from right to left

Since I don't want anyone reverting this, I'll refer you to Anubis' research log in "Prototype", episode 909. LD 03:20, 12 December 2005 (UTC)

I disagree, for a few reasons. Just because the text was aligned to the right doesn't mean that it is read from right to left. There was some text on the top left that was aligned to the left, and not the right. In addition, Anubis was using the language as code. He could have done anything to it to make it more difficult to decypher. What Anubis used isn't necessarily pure ancient. Also, we've seen Ancient text scroll in both directions. (But mostly from right to left, showing that the text would be read from left to right.) And I was watching 'The Siege', and some text written in Ancient is aligned in either direction, so we can't really assume that to mean anything at all. Also, when they are looking at a screen in the satellite's interior, and Grodin is pointing out the location of a circuit, the text scrolls in from left to right. If a civilization read their text from right to left, they wouldn't have their computers doing that. MioTheGreat 05:27, 3 January 2006 (UTC)

OK, you have me on some of those (for the moment), but as for your Grodin argument, I'll refer you to the Al-Jazeera news crawl, which, despite being written in the right-to-left Arabic script, moves from the left side of the screen to the right. Ahh, the advantages of multilinguality! LD 03:40, 29 January 2006 (UTC)

Just thought I would mention that in Atlantis (the city), the central staircase's writing on certain steps is upside down. This can also be seen in the Season 8 episode where Jacob/Selmak and Carter are trying to decipher the writing on the wall in the temple on Dakara and must rotate the sections of the wall 90 degrees in order to get the correct translation. There is first the question on whether or not we should go ahead and "translate" the text according to each symbol's Latin Alphabet equivalent. If that is indeed part of the process of determining which way the text is written, then it seems that when the symbols are right-side-up the text is written left to right and when the symbols are upside-down they are read right-to-left. It is possible that the creators of the show are attempting to establish that the Romans and Greeks (and whatever others) based their system of writing in both directions on this.

Cereal Killer 03:12, 12 February 2006 (UTC)


Visit SciFi.com/Atlantis. Move you mouse over the words like CAST, EPISODES, etc. The letters appear Left to Right.

Scifi.com is generally regarded as being someone inaccurate so I wouldn't go with that and it directly defies things shown onscreen, for example, the Glastonbury cavern in "Avalon", I translated the Ancient text into English and it was indeed left to right.

Faris b 20:50, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Bad Organization

Hi, After reading this article, and being well versed in stargate, it really seems that the layout of this article makes no sense. All the info is jumbled around in no order. Does anyone else agree that the info here needs to be re-sorted into better section titles in a diffrent order? Tobyk777 05:17, 12 February 2006 (UTC)

Hear, hear. Try to include a special section on language, OK? Lockesdonkey 01:33, 26 February 2006 (UTC)
I agree.--12.159.57.2 01:30, 7 March 2006 (UTC)

Any Idea as to how it should be reorganized?

[edit] How about this:

  • History
    • Ori Galaxy
    • Move to Milky way
    • Life in Milky way
    • Atlantis flight to Peagasus/partial move to peagasus
    • Life in Peaasus
    • Back from Atlantis
    • Life on earth
    • Ascension
  • Physiology
  • Philospsohy
    • Before Ascension
    • After Ascension
    • Current Ascended issues
  • Technology
  • Language
  • Known Ancients
  • See Also
  • Refrences
  • External Links

What do you think? -Tobyk777 04:39, 7 March 2006 (UTC)

  • Makes sense to me - nathanrdotcom (T • C • W) 04:43, 7 March 2006 (UTC)
Add language section. LD 13:24, 9 March 2006
Ok added. i also refined the plan a little. Tobyk777 05:53, 11 March 2006 (UTC)
Vote to execute plan, as per Tobyk's recommendations. Mind your capitals and spellings. LD 22:38, 12 March 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Lantians - Lanteans - Ancients - Alterans

Gateworld and other sources seem to make a clear distinction between Lantians and other Ancients, this article doesnt reflect that. Any comments or ideas? —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 12.159.57.2 (talk • contribs) 03:07, 7 March 2006 (UTC).

I know this is probably a few months too late but here's my take on it.

The Lanteans are a different sect/faction of Ancients than the Ancients. I mean, the Ancients were only called the Ancients when they came to the Milky Way, back in the Ori galaxy they were the Alterans and when they moved to Pegasus they renamed themselves the Lanteans. It's basically like different states or countries of them to distinguish their different societies and such.

--Faris b 08:37, 7 August 2006 (UTC)

I agree with the "it's like different namings", so Ancient = English ie. Milky Way name for any individual of the FIRST evolution of mankind, (At)Lanteans = Pegasus name after "Atlantis",
but then: Alteran = (is Latin for "the others" - and Latin was influenced by Merlin&Co-returners to Milky Way) all Ancients that left the Home Galaxy (now:OriGalaxy) for the Milky Way (explains the Alteran Communication Device MilkyWay<->OriGalaxy); Ori = group of people disagreeing with the technological ideology, preferring religion and staying home. cf.[1]. Hm. --FlammingoParliament 18:58, 9 November 2006 (UTC)
  • So what your saying is that these people basically change their name each time they move to another galaxy? -- SFH 01:23, 10 November 2006 (UTC)
    • No, it rather is being changed: I do not know what they call themselves, until now i only heard they refer to individuals of their (first) evolution as those "of our kind". But they are given different names according to circumstances: Ancients who live in Atlantis=Lantians, Atlanteans etc. And people who distinguish themselves (like an Opposition)= Others, or same in Latin altera.--FlammingoParliament 11:46, 10 November 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Extinction?

I added the word "presumably" to this phrase "They are presumably long since extinct", because Ancients have been discovered in suspended animation, and we don't know if there are others in suspended animation as well.--RLent 18:48, 9 March 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Difference, Comparisons and AKA's

Difference, Comparisons and Also Known As are needed to distinguish what are the differences between "Ancients" "Lantians" "Alterans" "Ori" "Evil ascended Beengs" "Gate Builders" which are all "Ascended Beengs" being braking down to 2 groups:

1) Alterans (aka "Ancients" "Gate Builders", "Alterans", "*Lantians", "*Atlanteans", "*Lanteans")

2) "Ori" (Evil ascended Beengs)

* May or May not refer to the earth explores that came to Atlantis, or known as the SGA team.


We all known that the Ancients are the Gate builder and what we know from early season 9; and later in season 9 SG1 (season 2 SG Atlantis) We learn that Ancients (Alterans) from Atlantis arent called Atlanians but in fact referred to as "Lantians" by some wraith and other human cultures.

The Ori are ascended beengs from the Alterans home galaxy. also known as Evil Ascended beings.

Anyone feel free to correct me i know i screwed up on something accidentally.--Gakhandal 03:28, 11 March 2006 (UTC)

Lantians? Atlanteans? Hmm. I've heard Atlanteans before too. - nathanrdotcom (T • C • W) 04:05, 11 March 2006 (UTC)
"Lantean" is the word used to refer to people living in atlantis.-- Alfakim --  talk  16:07, 10 April 2006 (UTC)


Please excuse me if I'm being obtuse or have missed something, but is there actually anywhere in the show where a Lantean identifies him or herself as being an Alteran or an Ancient? The reason I ask is that both Ayiana, and O'Neill when given Ancient knowledge/brain alterations, were able to perform incredible mental tasks (such as telekinesis) that has been identified as a state on the way to biological ascension. Ayiana was 5-10 million years behind the Lanteans seen in the Atlantis episodes "Before I Sleep" and "Aurora", yet none of the Lanteans seemed even vaguely capable of such tasks, nor did they seem capable of the extraordinary perception demonstrated by the Anubis clone in the SG-1 episode "Prototype". Thus, it would seem that the Ancients were on their way to biological ascension several million years before the Lanteans managed it, and even before the research into Ascension based on the energy being in (I think) "Hide and Seek".

While I grant that this is all original research, given the evidence I have presented, it seems to be no more unsubstantiated than the claim that the Ancients of Ayiana's time are the same people as the Lanteans when considering the vast differences between them. Can anyone shed light on this? --Despair 17:34, 20 April 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Age of the Ancients

"[Ancients] having evolved fifty million years prior to the present day and reaching their level of technology long before life had even evolved on Earth." There's been life on this planet for nearly a billion years. Is there any evidence from the shows that the Ancients are that old, or is this just an exaggeration? Jordan.Kreiger 13:10, 13 March 2006 (UTC)

No kidding. Someone apparently keeps changing this back. If someone knowns for certain please post something about it here. There is also a lot of cleanup yet some person or persons keeps reverting back to the obviously incorrect information. Aarlin81 17:55, 4 July 2006 (UTC)

  • I rember back in Frozen that Carter was talking to a scientist in Antarctica, and she said that the DHD found there was Fifty million years old. That's probably when they colonized Earth...or Terre or Avalon or whatever they call. God these people had a lot of names for things. But if I'm wrong about that, please correct me. -- SFH 23:48, 22 September 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Cleanup tag

Hi, I just tagged this article for cleanup because the organization is so horrible in this article. I don't know how the sections were formulated, but the way they were done doesn't make sense. I have already posted my proposal for the restructuing of this article on the talk page, but I only got one response. Also, even if I got approval, it would take more than one person to get this article right. Tobyk777 23:21, 17 April 2006 (UTC)

One response=nobody else cares=do it. Now. I would, but I have neither the time nor the patience nor the knowledge of the details of your plan (in spite of what you put above) to do it myself. LD 03:03, 18 April 2006 (UTC)
I decided to be bold and have reformatted the article. --Despair 18:30, 25 April 2006 (UTC)


[edit] Alterans and Ori?

Perhaps I missed something here but I know the name Ancients was given to the Alterans by early Romans. Ori is a name later associated with the ascended being who demand worship. It's been explained that the Ancients were once called the Alterans. Unless I missed something it was never explained whether this was the original name for their race (assuming the Ancients and Ori were once one race and not two living in the same galaxy or on the same planet), or a name that they took later after separating themselves from those later known as the Ori. It seems that someone is putting a whole lot of assumptions and pressumptions into this entire article. So I have decided to fix this until someone can show otherwise. Aarlin81 22:38, 16 May 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Inacuaracy

This article makes it sound as if all the ancients left for the peagasus. they didn't. Many were left behind. There has been technology found in the milky way from the time period that they were in the peagasus. Also, thor stated that the asgard elevloved about 30,000 years ago. It makes sense that if the great alliance came after that, but before the Goa'uld, it was between 25000 to 10,000 years ago, when the Ancients were in the peagasus. Reading the article it seems like Ayana was the only one left behind. She wasn't. The are other subtle inacuracies in this article. Depite them, I have to say that this article is improving. When I put the cleanup tag on, it was herendous, but its a little better now. Tobyk777 06:09, 23 May 2006 (UTC)

How many and who exactly? Technology found in the Milky Way either predates them leaving or was left when the returned (repository of the Ancients). Ayiana was the only non-ascended Ancient left behind. Orlin wasn't left behind. He was banished. No real timeline is given to his original ascension.
The Asgard evolved 30,000 years ago? I'm not entirely sure but which episode was this? I need to verify if he was referring to there current state (the used to look more human). However, as you state "evolved" not "came into being" so the alliance could have existed before the Alterans left for the Pegasus galaxy. Aarlin81 04:05, 24 May 2006 (UTC)
In the episode, Revelations (Stargate SG-1) it was explicitly stated that the Asgard were building thier first ships 30,000 years ago. This was about the time that they became super advanced. The Ancients are called the Ancients, even by the asgard, because they are Ancient. they came millions of years before the asgard. The alliance took place at about the time that the Ancients wer in the peagasus. It couldn't have been after they came back because in that time the Goa'uld had risen to power. Also, saying that only 1 Ancient was left behind, is also saying that all Ancient tech found by SG-1 is from over 5 million years ago. that just doesn't seem right. Tobyk777 04:21, 24 May 2006 (UTC)
Just checked out the episode. The 30,000 year reference points to when the ship (that was lost an drifted through space) was launched. Now given that timeline it does appear that the Asgard atleast joined the alliance during the time when the Ancients were in the Pegasus galaxy. However, when you consider that the Nox are Milky Way residents they would have been wiped out when the Ancients wiped out all life in the MW. However, the exact timelines of when the races joined (not always an alliance of 4) is unknown.
Now the Asgard do not call the Ancients the Ancients because they are Ancient. The name Ancients was given to them by the Romans. According to the mythology presented in SG-1, gods called the Ancient Ones taught the Romans (the first road builders) to build roads. This timeline coencides with their return to Earth.
Now the technology. You assume, incorrectly, that all technology found is from before they left. Not true. The repository/library of the Ancients would have likely been left after their return. The Ancients were still trekking around while the Goa'uld were playing around in the Milky Way (how many Goa'uld were in power at the time is not known exactly). Since all life was wiped out (except for Ayiana who was in the chamber at Dakara) any others left behind would have been wiped out. There has been no evidence to even suggest that any others were left behind (atleast not alive). So, Ancient outpost = 5 million years, repository/library = sometime after their return. Now wrap your heads around this. Because the alliance met in the Milky Way, it's likely that some Alterans were poking around and left some stuff, not people left behind. The others were doing some poking too (Furling Utopia). Aarlin81 02:41, 25 May 2006 (UTC)
Ayiana in the chamber at Dakara? dont you mean the site of the Stargate in antarctica? Also, An example of tech left behind by the ancients was the gate superweapon used by anubis in S6 - eps1/2.--Ross 21:25, 28 June 2006 (UTC)
Please read a little more carefully. Ayiana would likely have been protected from the device while in the chamber. Later, ON HER WAY BACK, via the stargate she was possibly caught in an avalanche. Aarlin81 17:59, 4 July 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Major work still needed

Hi, I just took another look at this article and did a major clean up of the history section (That section still needs alot of work). There is still alot of redundant info throughout the entire article, as well as tons of mising information throughout the entire article. Much of the article is unrefrenced, unorgaznied, and lacking of key details. For such a crucial article in Stargate, this defniately needs alot more work. Tobyk777 03:59, 26 June 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Over-confident.

I must say I'm surprised that my favourite WikiProject has neglected this article. Never fear, I am here. I intend to wikify and clean it all up myself... I'll make it a featured article. lol Your one true god is David P. A. Hunter, esq. III Talk to me! 09:48, 1 July 2006 (UTC)

Don't worry. I fully intend to help with this little project. Unfortunately, there are people who watch the show but apparently don't pay any attention what-so-ever. This means that after edits and cleanup are finished, some knuckle-head will revert the article to an earlier, sloppy version. For example someone actually wrote "While there is still a difference between the Alterans and the Ori, they are still one race, the Ancients". WHAT?!? Aarlin81 18:06, 4 July 2006 (UTC)
I was the one who put the cleanup tag on the article. As one of the most active members of the stargate project I have been cleaning it up little by little. It still has a very long way to go though. Tobyk777 19:30, 4 July 2006 (UTC)
OK, OK. Thank you. Happy now? Yes, this article needs a lot of work. It's a good thing I've got a TV, DVD player and seasons 1-8 sitting right behind me as I type this. So fact checking shouldn't be a problem. Aarlin81 04:12, 5 July 2006 (UTC)
I have all the seasons too, as well as Stargate Atlantis season 1. I even have a self-recoreded copy of seasons 9 and 2. I have watched every episode ever at least twice. I have been doing some fact checking too. However, this article was too broad of a topic for me to tackle alone. The article that I have put extrodniaruy effort into was DNA Resequencer, our best Stargate article now. Now that that one is vertualy complete (I think it's at FA standards), I'll start on this one, (but I may need help). This article has the potential to be longer than [[Stargate (device])]. It may even require subpages. That's why for my first huge effort I chose a smaller topic. Tobyk777 02:59, 6 July 2006 (UTC)
Yep, got the Atlantis DVD set too. Got some more stuff sitting on the DVR in the living room. It's gonna be tough going through this article. I just have to keep from drowning in the ocean of misinformation, blind praise, and various other stupidities with the Kevin Trudeau article. If I can stay afloat, I should have some time to spend on this one. Aarlin81 04:47, 7 July 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Reseeding Life and Nox in the Mily Way

Somebody decided to put a whoe lot of "incorrections" and assumptions in the section titled Milky Way (first time). It seems that the speculation that Aiayana, already infected, was left to "restart" life in the Milky Way was not right according to their assumptions.

Some fans,believe that the Dakara Device wiped out all life, it has the power certainly, to reseed life, for this to be true the Nox would not exist. The Device simply replenished life in the Milkyway.

This supposed assumption that the Nox wouldn't exist is apparently based on the alliance of the four great races. It has been stated that the Ancients restarted life in the Milky Way. The assumption that the Nox wouldn't be around is simply WRONG. There is NO timeline given as to when the alliance was formed. Beyond the Asgard's statements that it took many millenia (a millenium is 1000 years), there is no definitive time frame present in the show. It has never been established as to how old the Nox race is either. Given that the Alterans left Earth 5 million years ago (according to the SG:A pilot "Rising") it is perfefctly safe to theorize that the Nox would have had this time to come into being. That is of course if they are even from the Milky Way originally or settled there some time later. Given that all four races have had some type of purpose for being in the Milky Way which may be how the races came into contact with each other. It is also safe to assume that after life was restarted in the Milky Way, that the Lanteans would have possibly made treks to Earth from the Pegasus galaxy (possibly to meet with other alliance members. Given that any stargate could dial Earth (until they were locked out before they evacuated to Earth which is explained in the episode "Before I Sleep") it's pretty much a given that some might have made these treks. This could also have been how they met the other races given that all members have had some reason for being in the Milky Way (Lanteans - well duh, Nox - they live their, Asgard - study/exploration, Furlings - Utopia). Aarlin81 20:19, 25 July 2006 (UTC)

It isnt perfectly safe to therorize that the alliance was formed 5 million years ago. That is wrong. The Asgard were stated in the season 5 finale to have evolved to their current state 30,000 years ago and only had primitive spaceships at that time, thus the alliance was more recent than that. Since the Ancients came back from Atlantis 10,000 years ago, the Ancients had to be in the alliance after they came back. The first time they were in the milky way was too early for the asgard to be in the alliance. Plus, they wouldn't be called the Anceints by the asgard unless they were older than the other races. The Ancients had to have been in the alliance the second time they were in the milky way, making it 10,000 years ago, which was the time the asgard became super-advanced. No time frame was given for the nox, but they were in the alliance, and with the "Ancients" so like the asgard, they are probably more recent. Tobyk777 03:26, 26 July 2006 (UTC)
I never wrote that I believed the alliance was formed 5 million years ago. Sorry but when I wrote about all the other races being in the Milky Way I wasn't trying to establish any timeframe. That was simply to suggest that is where they would have likely met each other (or atleast the Nox and Asgard). I was refering to the where not when.
The Ancients aren't called the Ancients because they are older than any other race. They are called that because thhis is how the Romans knew them. The Ancients then adopted the term (We are the Ancients). It's more likely that the Asgard later adopted this term or that they joined the alliance after the Ancients began referring to themselves as the Ancients. Of course it could be that the writers had simply introduced them this way and didn't want to have 50 names for them from day one. It is quite possible that the Asgard were the last or second to last as well. We haven't seen the technological level of the Nox or the Furlings either. The 3 races might have been kicking around the alliance with the Asgard joining up later. The Asgard did mention that the alliance took many millenia to create. However, this does not make it clear if they mean as a whole or from when they joined up.

[edit] Altera/Alterans article should be separate from Ancients

Too much of this article makes the assumption that Alterans = Ancients and has nothing to do with the Ori. In Avalon part 2 Merlin's book reads

'Once upon a time, there was a race of people that went on a great journey through space, across the universe. They were called the Altera. After much time [thousands of years] they found a great belt of stars.' The Alterans named their new home Avalon and built many 'astria porta'

While there has been a lot of reference to the Alterans and the Ancients, it has yet to be established that the Ori were are also not (or were once) Altera. If time allows I will start determining how to separate these two. It seems that there is enough evidence to support the original species being called Altera while Alterans being some type of off-shoot or yet another name they gave themselves is pure speculation. The use of the phrase "RACE of people must be taken into consideration. Aarlin81 20:18, 25 July 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Alphabet

Where did that alphabet come from? The existence of 10 seperate digits contradicts The Fifth Race, in which it is shown (or at least heavily implied) that the Ancients used the Octal, and not the Decimal number system. (DrZarkov 08:04, 26 July 2006 (UTC))

With the airing of Atlantis the producers decided to come up with a real and standard Ancient language as apposed to the random symbols used in the previous seasons (aka The Fifth Race). The new alphabet was designed so the actually text shown in the episodes would mean what it was supposed to mean. There is an ancient symbol for each letter of the alphabet and a symbol for the numbers 0-9 as well. If you want to justify it, just call it a different dialect or something. --Paddyffrench 12:36, 27 July 2006 (UTC)
The Repository/Library of the Ancients works by downloading compressed data into the brain (likely subconcious which is believed to be able to store massive amounts of data). The information later unspools and writing itself into the persons concious mind (yet in no exact sequence). It's likely that as an advanced race the Ancients (Alterans) had developed quite a few numbering and mathematical systems. One need only look at our own history for a deeper understanding. Aarlin81 17:13, 27 July 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Known Ancients

It was inserted into the known ancients section that Melia and Ganos Lal are one in the same. Melia is given as the name of the Atlantian/Alteran counsel member. She is also shown to be in agreement with Moros at the counsel (regarding Janus' time travel experiment). Ganos Lal is the Alteran name of ANOTHER Lantian/Alteran whose rival is Moros. Both had avatars in Atlantis. One served to greet the expedition team while the other is a teaching and search tool. "Melia and Ganos Lal are one in the same. The former is the ascended form of the latter" is just plain wrong as both are names for PRE-ASCENDED Alterans. To claim that Melia (who was in two episodes of SG:A (Rising and Before I sleep), and Ganos Lal created the educational query tool as well as the avatar in her image. Only Ganos Lal (le Fay) is known to have taken on another persona.

Ganos Lal (Alteran) >> Morgan le Fay (later persona)
Melia (Alteran) >> no known alternate personas

Aarlin81 14:39, 29 July 2006 (UTC)

Could someone fix the Known Ancients section. There's a problem with the coding that leaves out Melia and Moros (AKA Merlin). I've tried messing with it but I can't seem to figure it out. Oh well back to the tutorials.

[edit] Alliances post season 10?

What is that new section about? Are they going to ally with some race this year or what is that all about?


--Faris b 22:20, 29 July 2006 (UTC)

[edit] My revert

I reverted the last edit [[2]]. Some of the info might be salvageable but it was filled with random capitalizations and a multitude of spelling mistakes (it is spelled Ori, not Orii). No offense to the editor but it had to be reverted. Perhaps someone can go over it and get ideas for what to contribute to the article. Konman72 08:07, 7 August 2006 (UTC)

I know I'm not the person who wrote it but in your defense, don't worry about it, I compared versions and the one that you reverted was much better, no offense to the writer of all that but the current info is much more accurate and such.

--Faris b 08:33, 7 August 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Phrases

Anyone have the official spelling of the planet which name means "Lost in Fire"? The Gateworld.net transcript spells it "PROKLARUSH TAONAS" with a "K" rather than a "C". -TheDevilYouKnow 03:05, 7 October 2006 (UTC)

  • It's spelt with a "c" instead of a "k". I watch SG-1 and Atlantis with closed captions. Trust me. This how I also know that Terra in Ancient was spelled "Terre" instead of "Terra". -- SFH 21:41, 7 October 2006 (UTC)
I definitely would not trust closed captions very much. I have watched them before and they misspell and use wrong words all the time. Konman72 22:06, 7 October 2006 (UTC)
  • Well, most of the transcripts I've seen also spell it as "Proclarush", as well as the Gateworld Omnipedia. -- SFH 22:36, 7 October 2006 (UTC)

[edit] Numbers orientation

Is it just me, or are the numbers on the alphabet photo upside down? I just watched 03x09 Phantoms, and in the end you can see Weir talking to Sheppard over radio, and there's Zelenka behind here standing in front of a console, which has numbers written on it, and they're upside down (if you compare them to the photo). I remember I also saw the numbers upside down before. Comments? RypER 20:46, 14 October 2006 (UTC)

Retrieved from "http://en.wikipedia.org../../../a/n/c/Talk%7EAncient_%28Stargate%29_c38b.html"